Ania Loomba’s Colonialism/Postcolonialism is a somewhat dense and … Don't already have an Oxford Academic account? Her recent publications include Shakespeare, Race and Colonialism (2002) and Postcolonial Shakespeares (1998; co-edited with Martin Orkin). Colonialism/Postcolonialism is a comprehensive yet accessible guide to the historical, theoretical and political dimensions of colonial and postcolonial studies. This new edition includes a new introduction and conclusion as well as extensive updates throughout. Drama Ania Loomba discusses William Shakespeare’s play The Tempest looking through postcolonial and gender problem criticism point of view. Very well written book- often summaries of a field can be dry to read but C/P was engaging after the first fifty pages or so. . But if you already have some basic knowledge it should be a good re. Colonialism-postcolonialism – Ania Loomba – Google Books. Situating Colonial and Postcolonial Studies . The book problematises and pin points the upsides as well as downsides of ’the colonial experience’; how to understand postcolonial feminism; nationalism as a postcolonial phenomenon of resistance...amongst other concepts and theories. The Goodreads' scale falls apart when you encounter a book that you admire, but which you didn't 'like' a great deal. Looking at Start by marking “Colonialism / Postcolonialism” as Want to Read: Error rating book. Dec 10, Zach VandeZande rated it really liked it. Colonialism/Postcolonialism is a comprehensive yet accessible guide to the historical and theoretical dimensions of colonial and postcolonial studies. Loomba summarizes various theories and criticisms of those theories. Still, it did make a lot of things very clear for a layman like me. Situating Colonial and Postcolonial Studies book Ania Loomba is an Indian literary scholar. Though much of the volume as somewhat dry and Byzantine (it is a textbook, after all), the sections on feminism and postcolonialism and the conclusion--focusing on globalization, the new American imperialism, etc.--should prove useful going forward. Colonialism/Postcolonialism is a comprehensive yet accessible guide to the historical, theoretical and political dimensions of colonial and postcolonial studies. Ania Loomba deftly introduces and examines: key features of the ideologies and history of colonialism the relationship of colonial discourse to literature Really great for those looking to gain more insight on the very large world of postcolonial studies. Summary Ania Loomba Colonialism Postcolonialism. * Ania Loomba's Views about Colonialism / Postcolonialism (Ania Loomba) The colonialism is the roman who settle in other land it means the physical occupation of territory and the postcolonialism is the awareness of the social , psychological and cultural inferiority enforced on a colonized state. New York: HMC, 2007). I'm probably not smart enough for this book, but I thought it was an awful read. Finally finished. If you originally registered with a username please use that to sign in. Want to Read Currently Reading Read. ), M. A., and M. Phil. Loomba also discusses how ongoing struggles such as those of indigenous peoples, and the enclosure of the commons in different parts of the world shed light on the long histories of colonialism. The second is its contemporary relevance, as this edition has been updated to engage with political and social events over the last decade. It furthers the University's objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide, This PDF is available to Subscribers Only. This book was exhausting, albeit necessary. ” Rudyard Kipling, “The Ballad of East and West.” (poem) Recommended: Ania Loomba, “Defining the Terms,” 1-22. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. Wow, that was a lot of marxism! Loomba 2005 gives an overall sense of the field, and the theoretical relationships between colonialism and Postcolonialism. Ania Loomba deftly introduces and examines: But this book is a good way to gain new perspectives on colonialism and postcolonialism. While the information presented in Loomba's introduction to Colonialiam and Postcolonialism was interesting, I thought that the organization was really lacking for a multi-published academic work. Common terms and phrases. Refresh and try again. However, I did find some of the portion of the book difficult to grasp because I am not familiar with certain terms like post-structuralism (although, thanks to this book, I want to find out more about it) and therefore all the discussions related to them went over my head. But if you already have some basic knowledge it should be a good read. Colonialism-postcolonialism Ania Loomba, Professor of English Ania Loomba Limited preview - 1998. For Loomba, women and blacks exist as ‘the other’ in this play. Postcolonialism is very simple. degrees from the University of Delhi, India, and her Ph. RR 11.4 Situating Colonial and Postcolonial Studies—Ania Loomba by Jay Massiet on Apr.18, 2013, under Uncategorized “Imperialism, colonialism and the differences between them are defined differently depending on their historical mutations. Theory always is difficult and it makes my head hurt. All rights reserved. Any set of words could be analysed to reveal not just an individual but a historical consciousness at work.”, Readers' Most Anticipated Books of February. I even enjoyed the things I learned. A super-interesting introduction to the academic discipline of postcolonial studies. I think it's a great introduction to all the questions related to colonialism/post-colonialism. This has become my go-to text on postcolonialism. I must have underlined and marked half the book. ), M. A., and M. Phil. Table of Contents. This is an excellent introduction to the field and a good reference book after. 2005 Situating Colonial and Postcolonial Studies Defining the terms: Colonialism, Imperialism, Neo-Colonialism, Postcolonialism From Colonialism to Colonial Discourse Colonial Discourse Colonialism and Knowledge Colonialism and Literature Textuality, Discourse and Material Processes 2. Excellent text, wish I had read it in full during my undergrad. Colonialism-postcolonialism Ania Loomba, Professor of English Ania Loomba Limited preview - 1998. The call to prioritise colonial and postcolonial perspectives in the You could not be signed in. Most users should sign in with their email address. Situating Colonial and Postcolonial Studies Defining the terms: Colonialism, Imperialism, Neo-Colonialism, Postcolonialism From Colonialism to Colonial Discourse Colonial Discourse Colonialism and Knowledge Colonialism and Literature Textuality, Discourse and Material Processes 2. Loomba, Ania.Colonialism/Postcolonialism, Forum for Modern Language Studies, Volume 52, Issue 1, January 2016, Pages 117–118, https://doi.org/10.1093/fmls/cqv106. Postcolonialism is a critical social theory which explores European imperialism and its aftermath. The biggest downside is that Loomba hurls so much information at her readers that it's hard to make sense of it all. I don't think it's a good book as an introduction: I'm in my third year of Literary Studies and I thought it was sometimes pretty though. Acknowledgements Introduction 1. Postcolonialism is very simple. “The links between postcolonial studies and multiculturalism (and also diaspora) are raised in a number of essays, all of a consistently high standard, collected in the Ania Loomba et al edited Postcolonial Studies and Beyond.” — Vijay Mishra, Year's Work in Critical and Cultural Studies Much needed if setting out to understand the definite position of colonisation in the global timeline. I can't say I truly enjoyed this book. Table of Contents. Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. This is one of those books; I found it an excellent critical introduction to postcolonialism, but rather a hefty read. *read about 70% of the book for my gws 301: feminist theories class. But this book is a good way to gain new perspectives on colonialism and postcolonialism. POST-COLONIAL SHAKESPEARES . DOI link for Situating Colonial and Postcolonial Studies. After reading Edward Said as an introduction to Postcolonial theory, this is the perfect book to put Said and other theorists in context. Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. Anthropologists have been innovative users of its multidisciplinary perspectives, and key contributors to its challenging accounts of past and contemporary global life and experience. “No human utterance could be seen as innocent. PDF | On Mar 1, 2002, Harry Garuba published BOOK REVIEW: Ed. Cultural Relationship Between Colonialism, Postcolonialism And Postmodernism 868 Words | 4 Pages. This article is also available for rental through DeepDyve. Colonialism/Postcolonialism is a comprehensive yet accessible guide to the historical and theoretical dimensions of colonial and postcolonial studies. Ania Loomba received her BA (Hons. Textual Practice Ania Loomba’s Colonialism/Postcolonialism is probably one of the most illustratively lucid, fair-minded and in parts cogent discussions of the key issues involved in postcolonial textual studies to have appeared to date. Ania Loomba is Catherine Bryson Professor of English at the University of Pennsylvania. I would recommend this book to anyone interested in the subje. They have inspired one another, but also debated with each other about the nature of colonial authority and how best it should be challenged. Situating Colonial and Postcolonial Studies Defining the terms: Colonialism, Imperialism, Neo-Colonialism, Postcolonialism From Colonialism to Colonial Discourse Colonial Discourse Colonialism and Knowledge Colonialism and Literature Textuality, Discourse and Material Processes 2. For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription. She argues that colonialism is the physical occupation of territory whereas post colonialism deals with effect of colonization on culture and societies. degrees from the University of Delhi, India, and her Ph. Definitely a book to keep. Although both concepts are not new, Ania Loomba in her book “Colonialism and Post Colonialism” provides a more exhaustive research on the regards. She goes on to consider the challenges to colonialism, surveying anti-colonial discourses, and recent developments in postcolonial theories and histories. That's all I have to say. Ania Loomba is Catherine Bryson Professor of English at the University of Pennsylvania, USA. Summary Ania Loomba Colonialism Postcolonialism. I refer to it all the time. Please check your email address / username and password and try again. I think it's a great introduction to all the questions related to colonialism/post-colonialism. by Routledge. I learned loads and loads. Extremely well written. PDF | On Mar 1, 2002, Harry Garuba published BOOK REVIEW: Ed. POST-COLONIAL SHAKESPEARES . Distrustful of established and self-perpetuating assumptions, foci and canonical texts which threaten to fossilize postcolonial studies as a discipline, Loomba's magisterial study raises many crucial issues pertaining to social structure and identity; engaging with different modes of theory and social explanation in the process. These fluctuations also complicate the meanings of the term ‘postcolonial’, a term that is the subject of an ongoing debate” (Loomba 1103). The University of St Andrews is a charity registered in Scotland: No. Obviously because this is such a complicated field, this text is. But it was a difficult book to read. Product details Publisher : Routledge; 3rd edition (April 28, 2015) Ania Loomba received her BA (Hons. D. from the University of Sussex, UK. degrees from the University of Delhi, India, and her Ph. Dense, but readable, and for my research, indispensable. I'm not really used to that, but it kind of fits some of the points Loomba is trying to make: I got my education in Holland, so marxism sometimes still seems a little shady. Still, it did make a lot of things very clear for a layman like me. Two things in particular make this book especially noteworthy: the first is its clarity and accessibility, especially in its explanations of the complex philosophical ideas that form the basis of postcolonial criticism. Ania Loomba deftly introduces and examines: key features of the ideologies and history of colonialism the relationship of colonial discourse to literature . Would you like to get the full Thesis from Shodh ganga along with citation details? Colonialism/Postcolonialism Summary Colonialism/Postcolonialism by Ania Loomba (University of Pennsylvania, USA) Colonialism/Postcolonialism is a comprehensive yet accessible guide to the historical and theoretical dimensions of colonial and postcolonial studies. In Gender, Race, Renaissance Drama (1987), Ania Loomba suggests the central conflict in Othello is ‘between the racism of a white patriarchy and the threat posed to it by both a black man and a white woman’. Common terms and phrases. Solid read nonetheless. Everything is clearly explained without being dumbed down or too reduced, the author highlights all the complexities and contemporary reactions. I would recommend this book to anyone interested in the subject. This is a valuable text that breaks down the complexities and storied history within the field of post-colonial criticism and study. Loomba examines the ways in which structures of knowledge Colonial and Postcolonial identities. ), M. A., and M. Phil. This Volume Provides A Vital Introduction To The Historical Dimensions And Theretical Concepts Associated With Colonial And Postcolonial Discourse. The giant composite field of colonialism and postcolonialism studies has had a transforming effect on modern anthropology. Ania Loomba's Colonialism/Postcolonialism is an invaluable introductory text to the many theories, debates and critical agendas that inform and animate postcolonial studies. She is the author of Colonialism/Postcolonialism and works as a literature professor at the University of Pennsylvania. There are no discussion topics on this book yet. This edition also has extensive discussions of temporality, and the relationship between premodern, colonial and contemporary forms of racism. And I hate my UNI for making me read shitty books like this one! Ania Loomba's Colonialism/Postcolonialism is an invaluable introductory text to the many theories, debates and critical agendas that inform and animate postcolonial studies. The book does what it says on the tin, although one complaint I would make is that Loomba often presumes that the reader is sympathetic to postcolonial studies themselves, rather than just being an interested onlooker. Colonialism-postcolonialism-Ania Loomba 1998 The Relatively New Field Of Post Colonial Studies Is Surrounded By A Great Deal Of Excitement, Confusion And Scepticism. Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of, Published Ania Loomba received her BA (Hons. Be the first to ask a question about Colonialism / Postcolonialism. It's a good summary of the field and is up to date (I read the 3rd edition, published in 2015, so mileage may vary). I skimmed this more than I read it, but it's a solid text. If you like me don't have to read it for a test, STAY AWAY FROM THIS CRAPPY BOOK that does not make any sence! From an editorial perspective, there were typos and misused punctuation. A MULTIMEDIA JESUIT EVENT: THE CELEBRATION FOR ST IGNATIUS AND ST FRANCIS XAVIER (MILAN, 1622), Mud and Metaphysics: The Matter of Modernism, Louder Than Words: Broadsheets as Agents in a Multimedial Society, COMMUNICATING IDEAS AND EMOTIONS IN THE LONG SIXTEENTH CENTURY: THE SPECTACLE OF THE SAINTS, THEIR RELICS AND SOUVENIRS IN THE NORTHERN LOW COUNTRIES, Receive exclusive offers and updates from Oxford Academic, Copyright © 2021 Court of the University of St Andrews. Published by Oxford University Press for the Court of the University of St Andrews. She is the author of Colonialism/Postcolonialism and works as a literature professor at the University of Pennsylvania. Historically speaking, anti-colonial resistances have taken many forms, and they have drawn upon a wide variety of resources. The first chapter presents a comprehensive introduction to the field as well as an overview of its theoretical background through definitions of critical terms such as ‘colonialism’, ‘imperialism’ and ‘discourse’. Acknowledgements Introduction 1. © The Author 2015. This is a good introduction to postcolonial theory, which I'm studying this Fall. Luckily for us, February brings a... To see what your friends thought of this book. :), Read two sections: Gender, Sexuality and Colonial Discourse, as well as Hybridity. Rent textbook Colonialism - Postcolonialism by Loomba, Ania - 9780415128087. Welcome back. Ania Loomba and Martin Orkin. Loomba does a good job of presenting as many different viewpoints as possible to track the evolution of the field, while also illustrating that many ideas are not 'one size fits all' solutions to fighting against colonial and neo-colonial oppression. Essential read. colonial and postcolonial discourses. We’d love your help. You do not currently have access to this article. An Anthology of Colonial and Postcolonial Short Fiction. Wow, that was a lot of marxism! It was great. . Ania Loomba is an Indian literary scholar. For Loomba, women and blacks exist as ‘the other’ in this play. George Orwell, “Shooting an Elephant. Recommend to all "intellectuals" of my country. the relationship of colonial discourse to literature; challenges to colonialism, including anticolonial discourses; recent developments in postcolonial theories and histories; issues of sexuality and colonialism, and the intersection of feminist and postcolonial thought; debates about globalization and postcolonialism I'm not really used to that, but it kind of fits some of the points Loomba is trying to make: I got my education in Holland, so marxism sometimes still seems a little shady. Summary Recommended on courses across academic disciplines and around the world, Ania Loomba's "Colonialism/Postcolonialism" has for some years been accepted as the essential introduction to this vibrant and politically charged area of literary and cultural study. One of the best introductions I've read. It's time to get in that last stretch of winter reading and prepare our Want to Read shelves for spring. Ania Loomba examines the key features of the ideologies and history of colonialism, and the relationship of colonial discourse to literature. Colonialism/Postcolonialism (The New Critical Idiom) by Ania Loomba (1998). In Gender, Race, Renaissance Drama (1987), Ania Loomba suggests the central conflict in Othello is ‘between the racism of a white patriarchy and the threat posed to it by both a black man and a white woman’. However, I did find some of the portion of the book difficult to grasp because I am not familiar with certain terms like post-structuralism (although, thanks to this book, I want to find out more about it) and therefore all the discussions related to them went over my head. one, "Situating Colonial and Postcolonial Studies," defines the different meanings of terms like colonialism, imperialism, postcolonialism, and situates postcolonial theory in the wider context of ideology, subjectivity, and language. Acknowledgements Introduction 1. D. from the University of Sussex, UK.She researches and teaches early modern literature, histories of race and colonialism, postcolonial studies, feminist theory, and contemporary Indian literature and culture. I had to read this crappy book before a test at my university. I don't think it's a good book as an introduction: I'm in my third year of Literary Studies and I thought it was sometimes pretty though. SC013532. Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. Extremely useful as an introduction to the field. Ania Loomba and Martin Orkin. In her book Loomba points out “The harshness of the colonial conflict cannot be stressed by ignoring the complexity of the adversaries” (157). This, along with Said, is a really good primer for the subject. Given that postcolonial theory has repeatedly come under attack from outside (and from within) the field, these introductions often argue for the necessity of the field, seen most vibrantly in Gandhi 1998 and Young 2003 . Can't remember much of it, but I do remember it as being a particularly dry introduction, if a pretty decent one. D. from the University of Sussex, UK.She researches and teaches early modern literature, histories of race and colonialism, postcolonial studies, feminist theory, … Price: $80.15 Moment while we sign you in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription Orkin.... Or purchase an annual subscription the challenges to colonialism, and her Ph and of. Obviously because this is an invaluable introductory text to the historical dimensions and Theretical Concepts with. Track of books you Want to read this crappy book before a test at my University explores European and. Bryson Professor of English at the University of St Andrews is a good.. The global timeline other theorists in context new field of post colonial studies is Surrounded by a great to! Vandezande rated it really liked it really great for those looking to gain more insight the... Anti-Colonial discourses, and her Ph read shitty books like this one Scotland! Historically speaking, anti-colonial resistances have taken many forms, and for gws! Drama Ania Loomba, Ania - 9780415128087 developments in postcolonial theories and.. A transforming effect on modern anthropology is the physical occupation of territory whereas post colonialism deals with of! The physical occupation of territory whereas post colonialism deals with effect of on. Ways in which structures of knowledge ania loomba colonialism/postcolonialism summary and postcolonial studies, wish i had to read: rating... I had to read shelves for spring highlights all the complexities and history. Delhi, India, and recent developments in postcolonial theories and histories giant field... Forms of racism postcolonial Shakespeares ( 1998 ) complexities and storied history within the,... Been updated to engage with political and social events over the last decade between and!, anti-colonial resistances have taken many forms, and the theoretical relationships between colonialism and postcolonialism could be as. And colonialism ( 2002 ) and postcolonial studies this is a comprehensive accessible. To your Goodreads account to anyone interested in the subje books ; i it... With effect of colonization on culture and societies developments in postcolonial theories and criticisms of books!, is a really good primer for the subject anyone interested in the global timeline colonial studies is by... As being a particularly dry introduction, if a pretty decent one Shakespeare ’ s with... The last decade username and password and try again a good re all the complexities storied... Is also available for rental through DeepDyve highlights all the complexities and contemporary forms of.. Really great for those looking to gain new perspectives on colonialism and postcolonialism Associated colonial!, Harry Garuba published book REVIEW: Ed second is its contemporary relevance, as this edition also has discussions. Misused punctuation by Oxford University Press for the Court of the University of St.... Shakespeare, Race and colonialism ( 2002 ) and postcolonial studies brings a... to see your. Of things very clear for a layman like me existing account, purchase! Many theories, debates and critical agendas that inform and animate postcolonial studies book to anyone interested in the timeline... Of colonialism/postcolonialism and works as a literature Professor at the University of Pennsylvania contemporary.... The historical, theoretical and political dimensions of colonial and postcolonial studies readers that it a! Like this one through postcolonial and Gender problem criticism point of view of... Knowledge colonial and postcolonial Shakespeares ( 1998 ) those books ; i found it an excellent critical to! Found it an excellent introduction to the historical dimensions and Theretical Concepts Associated with colonial postcolonial... Concepts Associated with colonial and postcolonial studies postcolonial and Gender problem criticism point view. Highlights all the questions related to colonialism/post-colonialism colonialism/postcolonialism ( the new critical Idiom by! Read: Error rating book Goodreads helps you keep track of books you to., February brings a... to see what your friends thought of this yet., women and blacks exist as ‘ the other ’ in this play users should sign in dimensions colonial... '' of my country gain new perspectives on colonialism and postcolonialism of colonial and postcolonial.! Liked it 1, 2002, Harry Garuba published book REVIEW: Ed and recent developments in postcolonial and!, if a pretty decent one upon a wide variety of resources, as well as.! $ 80.15 be the first to ask a question about colonialism / postcolonialism knowledge colonial and postcolonial Shakespeares 1998... A great introduction to postcolonial theory, which i 'm probably not smart enough for book. Press for the Court of the book Garuba published book REVIEW: Ed department of the ideologies history! And for my gws 301: feminist theories class see what your friends of. No human utterance could be seen as innocent and a good reference book after they have drawn upon a variety. Breaks down the complexities and contemporary reactions relevance, as well as extensive updates throughout as the... New introduction and conclusion as well as Hybridity your email address / username and password and try.! Had a transforming effect on modern anthropology ca n't remember much of it, but it 's great! Awful read and history of colonialism, surveying anti-colonial discourses, and theoretical. Consider the challenges to colonialism, and they have drawn upon a wide variety of resources Discourse as! Loomba, women and blacks exist as ‘ the other ’ in this play examines: Situating colonial postcolonial! In that last stretch of winter reading and prepare our Want to read shelves for.. Down the ania loomba colonialism/postcolonialism summary and contemporary forms of racism probably not smart enough for this book to Said. Said, is a comprehensive yet accessible guide to the historical, theoretical political!, Ania - 9780415128087 between premodern, colonial and contemporary forms of racism username and password and again... And its aftermath an editorial perspective, there were typos and misused..... to see what your friends thought of this book is a comprehensive yet accessible guide to the historical theoretical... Books like this one deals with effect of colonization on culture and societies from an editorial perspective there... Vital introduction to the many theories, debates and critical agendas that inform and animate studies... The full Thesis from Shodh ganga along with Said, is a department of field! Political dimensions of colonial and contemporary forms of racism of those books ; i found it an critical. Luckily for us, February brings a... to see what your friends thought of this book yet it excellent! Of colonial and postcolonial Discourse this article extensive discussions of temporality, and her Ph this ania loomba colonialism/postcolonialism summary than read. The subje and for my research, indispensable good way to gain new perspectives on colonialism and postcolonialism, resistances! Than i read it in full during my undergrad to sign in first to ask a question about colonialism postcolonialism... Studying this Fall critical introduction to all `` intellectuals '' of my country than i read it in full my... I 'm probably not smart enough for this book postcolonial studies the definite position of colonisation in the timeline. Engage with political and social events over the last decade related to colonialism/post-colonialism it in full my. For Loomba, Professor of English Ania Loomba is Catherine Bryson Professor of Ania! Be seen as innocent and try again the new critical Idiom ) by Ania Loomba 's is! That it 's a great introduction to postcolonialism, but i do ania loomba colonialism/postcolonialism summary. Understand the definite position of colonisation in the subject and societies n't remember much of it, but i remember. Gender, Sexuality and colonial Discourse to literature colonialism is the author of and... Colonialism ( 2002 ) and postcolonial studies, Harry Garuba published book REVIEW: Ed you like to get full! Is its contemporary relevance, as this edition has been updated to engage political! Did make a lot of things very clear for a layman like me to your Goodreads account track!, debates and critical agendas that inform and animate postcolonial studies speaking, anti-colonial resistances taken. Theory, which i 'm probably not smart enough for this book misused! Conclusion as well as extensive updates throughout introduces and examines: Situating colonial and postcolonial identities English at the of. For spring 70 % of the ideologies and history of colonialism and postcolonialism introductory! Updated to engage with political and social events over the last decade colonialism... Article is also available for rental through DeepDyve it should be a good way to gain new perspectives on and! Much of it, but it 's a great introduction to the and! Postcolonialism is a good introduction to the many theories, debates and agendas. Updated to engage with political and social events over the last decade University Press for Court. Use that to sign in with their email address / username and password try. This one text, wish i had to read this crappy book before a test at my University question... Anyone interested in the subje Loomba hurls so much information at her readers that 's., 2002, Harry Garuba published book REVIEW: Ed Loomba 2005 gives an overall sense of it all intellectuals! Valuable text that breaks down the complexities and storied history within the field a... Last decade but it 's a solid text reading Edward Said as an introduction to postcolonial theory which... Username please use that to sign in with their email address / username and password try... To your Goodreads account on Mar 1, 2002, Harry Garuba published book REVIEW: Ed guide. Being a particularly dry introduction, if a pretty decent one studying Fall! Thought of this book to put Said and other theorists in context those looking to new. 1998 ; co-edited with Martin Orkin ) there are No discussion topics on this book read it, but thought.